REGIONAL TRADE LIBERALISATION AS A PRISONERS’ DILEMMA GAME: UNDERSTANDING THE EFFECTS OF STRATEGIC FACTORS ON REGIONAL COOPERATION

  • Mopeli L. Moshoeshoe
Keywords: Regionalism, Southern Africa, prisoners’ dilemma, international cooperation, free trade

Abstract

African governments regularly advocate regionalism as a means for facilitating economic development, but the record of intergovernmental cooperation to implement regional initiatives has been disappointing. Conventional explanations for this record are based on a simplistic portrayal of the challenges of cooperation; if it is in the interest of governments to cooperate, they do, if not, they do not. This article uses an alternative framework, derived from a game-theoretic perspective to show that regional trade liberalisation initiatives do not succeed or fail simply because of the presence or absence of mutual gains from cooperation. I employ the ‘game theoretic’ analysis to illustrate that attempts by a group of self-interested governments to reap mutual gains from trade liberalisation encounter a strategic problem commonly known as the Prisoners’ Dilemma .The inability to overcome this type of problem explains why regional initiatives may fail despite their obvious potential for being mutually rewarding and enjoying the support of participant governments. This study uses the SADC trade liberalisation initiative to illuminate the collective action problem that typically afflicts similar initiatives and how it can be resolved. The aim is not just to present a new theoretical perspective on regional cooperation in Africa, but also to illuminate the practical challenges that must be addressed if African trade liberalisation initiatives are to succeed.

References

Baloi O. 1999. 'Mozambique to ratify SADC trade protocol before 1999.' Midweek Sun. www. online-newspapers.com/Botswana.html [accessed March 2006].

Bienen H. 1990. The politics of Trade liberalisation in Africa. Economic Development and Cultural Change 38: 713-732.

https://doi.org/10.1086/451830

Chauvin S. and Guillamme Gaulier. 2002. 'Prospects for Increasing Trade among SADC Countries,' Paper presented at annual forum, 21-22 November. Johannesburg.

Cosatu 1999. Submission on the SADC Protocol on Trade (presentation to the joint sitting of the Portfolio Committees on Trade and Industry, Foreign Affairs, Agriculture and Land Affairs and the NCOP select Committee on Economic Affairs 25 October Cape Town.

Dimitrakopoulos D. 2005. 'Norms, Interests and Institutional Change.' Political Studies 53: 668.

https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9248.2005.00551.x

Erwin A. 1998. South Africa and the SADC Trade Protocol. Paper presented at a conference on regional integration in Southern Africa, 27 October. Johannesburg, SAIIA.

Flatters F. 2002. 'SADC Rules of Origin: Undermining Regional Free Trade.' Paper prepared for TIPS Forum, 9-11 September, Johannesburg.

Government of Botswana, 2012. 'Control of Goods, Prices and Other Charges Regulations of 2003,' in http://www.mti.gov.bw [Accessed on August 16, 2012].

Harries C.J. and Kishore G. Kulkani 2004. "The Role of International Trade Policy on Economic Growth: A Case of Tanzania," Global Business Review.

Harrington W. 2006. Quoted in The Times of Zambia, Lusaka, 3 January.

Imani Development Austral, 2004. Inventory of Regional Non-Tariff Barriers: Synthesis Report, 7, November.

Mabuza Z, 2006. Presentation on SADC Finance and Investment Protocol. Maseru.

Mattli W. 1999. The Logic of Regional Integration: Europe and Beyond. Cambridge; Cambridge University Press.

https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511756238

Mbeki, T. 2008. Speech at the Launching of the SADCFTA, 17 August, Midrand South Africa. http://www.polity.org.za/article/sa-mbeki-launch-of-free-trade-area-at-sadc-summit-17082008-2008-08-17

Mccarty and Adam Meirowitz. 2007. "Political Game theory," Cambridge, New York, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, Sao Paulo: Cambridge University Press.

Ministry of Finance. 2004. 'The revenue implications of the SADC Free Trade Area for Zambia -The Baseline Revenue Loss.' Lusaka.

Mistry P. 2000. 'Africa's Record of Regional Co-operation and Integration.' African Affairs 99; 553-573.

https://doi.org/10.1093/afraf/99.397.553

Mkapa B.W. 2004. Foreword of the SADC Regional Indicative Strategic Development Plan. Gaborone.

Mshomba, Richard E. 2000. Africa in the Global Economy. Boulder: Lynne Reinner.

Nathan-MSI Group 2004. The final report for SADC/TIFI. USAID, Washington D.C.

Ng'ong'ola, C. 2000. "Regional Integration and Trade Liberalisation in the Southern African Development Community," Journal of International Economic Law, 3: 485-506.

https://doi.org/10.1093/jiel/3.3.485

Ngwenya S. 2000. Quoted in The Zimbabwe Mirror, Harare, 20 January.

Rodrik D. 1998. "Why is trade reform so Difficult in Africa?" Journal of African Economies, 7; 43-69.

https://doi.org/10.1093/jafeco/7.suppl_1.10

SACU Secretariat 2002. The review of the 1969 SACU Agreement. Windhoek.

SADC (undated). 'SADC Secretariat issues paper: Accelerating the SADC regional economic integration agenda,' A working document, unpublished.

SADC 1996. The SADC Protocol on Trade. 24 August, Maseru.

SADC, 2008. "SADC Free Trade Area: Growth Development and Wealth Creation," (SADC Handbook. Gaborone. The Services Group 2004. The mid-term review of the SADC Trade Protocol. Gaborone.

TIPS 2008. SADC free trade area; growth development and wealth creation.

USAID 2010. Audit report on the implementation of the SADC Protocol on Trade. Southern African Global Competitiveness Hub, (SA Trade Hub; undated paper). Accessed, January 11, 2012.

World Trade Organisation Secretariat. 2008. "Factual Report on Trade," based on data provided by respective SADC member states.

Published
2017-02-16
Section
Articles